As part of my Ph.D. research, this paper focuses on the procedure of planning and destruction of the old bazaar surrounding the shrine of Imam Reza in Mashhad-Iran from 1967 to 1978, which has created a conflict between the inhabitants and the custodian of the shrine, the Pahlavi state. The custodian of the shrine manages and regulates pilgrimage in this urban site since the 16th century. By looking at the practices of the managers, city planners, and architects during 1960s and 70s, I analyze the power relations, professional discourses, and rhetoric, which represent their vision for this sacred site. I illustrate how their positions and interactions on different problems, as experts, influenced greatly the outcome of which they sometimes intriguingly question. The exposition of their doubts and perceptions about this urban development is reflected in archival documents from that era. When looking at the shrine’s associated architectural firms, the notion of hierarchy is not always helpful since it does not display the power-relations coherently. Ethnography of power-relations presents the importance of “informal power”, namely, the significance of “shadow elites” alongside the influence of the “key figures”. The tension between different representations of the sacred space, by the custodian (the state) and the associated architectural firms, speaks about the deeper questions of different logics and conceptions of sacrality and is not simply reducible to the conflicts based around issues of benefits, interests, and resources. The study connects the architect’s intentionalities to the context where they were able to perform as experts by demonstrating their subtle strategies and technologies of power in their struggle to implement their vision for this sacred space. It examines the process of modern development to explore how the sacredness of this site is shaped by the state, as much as it is providing the state with the legitimacy of a sovereign during a decade before the Islamic revolution of 1978-9.
- About
- Membership
- Publications
- Conferences
- Resources
- Awards
- Saidi-Sirjani Book Award
- AIS Book Prize
- Latifeh Yarshater Award
- Lifetime Achievement Award
- Best Dissertation Award
- Yarshater Book Award
- The Parviz Shahriari Book Award
- Hamid Naficy Book Award
- Diaspora Studies Dissertation Award
- Nemati Book Award
- Conference to Journal Paper Award
- Graduate Student Research Award
- Mohammad Amini Memorial
- Mentorship Award
- Initiatives
